Shelter Island
Photographer’s midcentury A-frame on Shelter Island asks $799K
The house is in need of a renovation (it doesn’t look like it’s been touched since the ’60s), but we think that the midcentury time capsule would make a great fixer-upper project.
The Ram’s Head Inn on Shelter Island is for sale, asking $9.75M
The 4.3-acre property has a 22-room inn, space for private events and weddings, a tennis court, and a restaurant
Waterfront stunner on Shelter Island is yours for $5.3M
Considering the size of the house and the fact that it’s waterfront, the price doesn’t seem too bad—but the downside is that it’s only on a half-acre of land.
Waterfront home on Shelter Island cuts price, now almost half of original ask
After five years and another price cut, the Victorian style home is listed for nearly half of its original ask: $4.9 million.
What $1M buys you on Shelter Island right now
Let’s see what this budget gets you here
Renovated shingled farmhouse from 1930 on Shelter Island quickly goes into contract
Located at 53 North Cartwright Road, the move-in ready home offers 2,000 square feet, four bedrooms, and two and a half bathrooms on almost a full acre of land.
Own 20 acres of waterfront land on Shelter Island for $14.2M
The largest parcel currently available for sale on Shelter Island spans 20 acres—and it’s waterfront on West Neck Creek.
Gorgeous waterfront retreat in North Haven wants $9.75M
In 2005, the property sold for $1.57 million and the current house was finished three years later in 2008. Though it’s been available to rent in the past, this is the first time that it’s come on the sales market.
Renovated shingled beauty on Shelter Island asks $925K
This gorgeous shingled farmhouse at 53 North Cartwright Road is just one example of the many great homes that are on the market for less than $1 million.
A Carpenter Gothic Victorian from 1887 on Shelter Island asks $1.275M
Some of the best 19th century features of this 131-year-old historic district home include the hardwood floors, paneled walls and ceilings, the stone fireplace in the living room, and the chapel style doors off the second-level bedrooms that lead out to a porch and bring you back in time.
Rent a historic Shelter Island waterfront home this summer for $160K
It was once the summer home of the former Governor of New York, Hugh L. Carey
Shelter Island home from 1770 lists for $1.15M
Inside, one will find a brick fireplace, wide plank floors, a wood stove, marble counter tops in the kitchen, and an ensuite master bedroom.
Waterfront Hamptons home designed by Maria-Rosaria Piomelli asks $3M
Outside, there’s decking, bulkheaded water frontage, and room for a pool and tennis court on the two-acre property.
A boxy Shelter Island modern home seeks $1.85M
There are winter water views of the Peconic River, which are visible from the main living space through the high windows and sliding glass doors.
Curbed Cup 1st round: (6) Southampton vs. (11) Shelter Island
Which neighborhood should advance? Vote!
Former New York Governor Hugh Carey’s Shelter Island summer home cuts asking price, now $7.95M
The home sits on almost two acres of land on the northern side of Shelter Island, with about 200 feet of waterfront directly on the Peconic River.
What you can get in North Haven right now for under $2M
North Haven sits, appropriately, just north of Sag Harbor and has access to the Shelter Island Ferry.
What $2M buys you on Shelter Island
Let’s see what a $2M budget will get you in the patch of land between the North and South Forks.
The most expensive home for sale on Shelter Island slashes $7M off the asking price
The $7 million cut was 21.9 percent of the original asking price. The home went down by $1,000 per square foot—from $4,571 per square foot to $3,571 per square foot.
Hamptons real estate market report: Q2 of 2017
Bridgehampton, Amagansett, Hampton Bays, Westhampton, Southampton, and Sag Harbor village all saw increases in total number of home sales, while the greater Sag Harbor area, Shelter Island, East Hampton, and Montauk all saw decreases.
3 Hamptons homes with outdoor kitchens
Outdoor kitchens are perfect for enjoying the weather in the summer and the quickly-approaching fall. Bon appetit!
What $900K buys you in Shelter Island
Today, we’re looking moving a bit north and off the South Fork to Shelter Island to see what a $900,000 budget will get you.
Shelter Island home sees its second price cut after almost three years on the market
Almost $4 million has been taken from the asking price since the home has gone on the market.
Artist Joseph La Piana’s Shelter Island home is on the market for $1.65M
The two bedroom, two bath home was built in 1972 on 2.3 acres of land, but was recently restored and features cedar and brick stone surfaces on the interior.
Go green: Hamptons homes for sale with greenhouses
For those passionate about growing their own herbs, Curbed has brought you four homes for sale with greenhouses right on the property.
Ranking Hamptons towns by affordability
Living in the Hamptons can be rather expensive, but it’s still possible to find a bargain.
Hamptons homes with deepwater docks
These homes all come with deepwater docks right on the property. Everyone needs a place to store their yacht, right?
Historic Shelter Island property built in 1883 listed for sale
The home was originally owned by the famous minister who delivered a speech for Abraham Lincoln, and a prayer at the opening ceremony for the Brooklyn Bridge.
The 10 most expensive homes available on the North Fork right now
Most of the homes here are on Shelter Island. And many have lot sizes you won’t find on the South Fork.
5 Hamptons homes offices with very different styles
A home office can mean something different to every individual. Which is why no two Hamptons home offices are the same.
Open houses this week: Waterfront beauties
Take a dip into these homes
The best waterfront North Fork summer rentals available right now
Snag one while you still can
Shelter Island Heights inn listed for $11.9M
With a $11,995,000 asking price, the historic Ram’s Head Inn is on the market with a little over four acres of land and 17 guest rooms. The 15,500-square-foot property has a dining room that can seat 180.
Charming Shelter Island farmhouse with guest cottage asks $875K
This 1920s farmhouse includes many charming, homey details. There’s also a garage and a separate guest cottage with living room, kitchen, bedroom and bath.
Curbed Cup 1st Round: Hampton Bays (4) vs. Shelter Island (13)
The Curbed Cup, our annual award to the Hamptons neighborhood of the year, is kicking off with 16 towns/villages/hamlets vying for the prestigious fake trophy.
Festive fun at the Chequit’s tree lighting party tomorrow
Enjoy the 15-foot tree, cookie and ornament decorating, a Santa photo booth, and a bake sale, all while being serenaded by Victorian carolers.
Dopo la Spiaggia and Vine Street Cafe will both open new East Hampton eateries
Dopo East Hampton will open soon in the former Race Lane; Shelter Island’s Vine Street Cafe is also planning an East Hampton outpost.
A funky glass-walled contemporary on Shelter Island for $925K
This house looks very 60s California modern to us, but is actually 80s. An enormous living space has a soaring ceiling and a wall of windows.
What you can buy in the Hamptons for $1.5M
We're looking at properties for sale in East Hampton, Shinnecock, Shelter Island, and Montauk. Which one is the best?