clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

The Hottest Rental Neighborhoods in the Hamptons

View as Map

Today, we're mapping the hottest neighborhoods in the Hamptons for rentals. Of course, one of the charms of the Hamptons is the variety of the landscape, from sedate Southampton village streets to surfing spots in Montauk. We've picked out some of the more interesting choices in the map. Did we forget your favorite? Mention it in the comments.

Read More
Eater maps are curated by editors and aim to reflect a diversity of neighborhoods, cuisines, and prices. Learn more about our editorial process.

Meadow Lane

Copy Link

Billionaire Lane is not only oceanfront, but is close to the amazing shops and dining of Southampton Village. Rent this Norman Jaffe for $650K, July-LD.

Sagaponack

Copy Link

Sagaponack is a hot neighborhood for those who want to escape the city and gaze over tranquil farm fields. Rent your own slice of heaven for $250K for July.

Sag Harbor

Copy Link

This beautiful, charming village is great for strolling. Enjoy great restaurants and theater and watch the yachts come in to the harbor. This c. 1750 rental is available for $325K, MD-LD.

Shelter Island

Copy Link

Shelter Island offers a more laid back alternative to the frenetic pace of much of the Hamptons, along with lower prices. Rent this lovely house and carriage house for only $90K July-LD.

Amagansett Lanes

Copy Link

The quiet Amagansett Lanes are a great choice for families. Walk to town or the beach from this rental, asking $135K for July-LD.

Lazy Point

Copy Link

Windsurfers, kite boarders and clammers know and love Lazy Point. Rent this waterfront cottage for $39K MD-LD.

Ditch Plains

Copy Link

Surfers flock to the best waves on Long Island, and hipster love the Montauk nightlife. Be a part of it in this rental with pool asking $225K for MD-LD.

Meadow Lane

Billionaire Lane is not only oceanfront, but is close to the amazing shops and dining of Southampton Village. Rent this Norman Jaffe for $650K, July-LD.

Sagaponack

Sagaponack is a hot neighborhood for those who want to escape the city and gaze over tranquil farm fields. Rent your own slice of heaven for $250K for July.

Sag Harbor

This beautiful, charming village is great for strolling. Enjoy great restaurants and theater and watch the yachts come in to the harbor. This c. 1750 rental is available for $325K, MD-LD.

Shelter Island

Shelter Island offers a more laid back alternative to the frenetic pace of much of the Hamptons, along with lower prices. Rent this lovely house and carriage house for only $90K July-LD.

Amagansett Lanes

The quiet Amagansett Lanes are a great choice for families. Walk to town or the beach from this rental, asking $135K for July-LD.

Lazy Point

Windsurfers, kite boarders and clammers know and love Lazy Point. Rent this waterfront cottage for $39K MD-LD.

Ditch Plains

Surfers flock to the best waves on Long Island, and hipster love the Montauk nightlife. Be a part of it in this rental with pool asking $225K for MD-LD.