clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

10 Fixer-Uppers on the Market in the Hamptons

Prices ranging from $365K to $5.75M

View as Map
renovation-week

Sure, these properties need some love, elbow grease and a pile of cash to look their best, but that’s where you come in. In honor of Curbed Renovation Week, we’ve mapped a fixer-upper worth the investment in various Hamptons towns, from a 620 square foot Noyack cottage to a contemporary near the ocean in Sagaponack.

Read More
Eater maps are curated by editors and aim to reflect a diversity of neighborhoods, cuisines, and prices. Learn more about our editorial process.

Shinnecock

Copy Link

Asking price: $1.6M
Size: 4 bedroom, 3 bath, 3730sf, 0.4 acre
The skinny: This spacious house is suffering from a bad case of the 1990s. Of course, the real star here is the 148 feet of frontage on the Great Peconic Bay. It’s all about the views.

North Sea

Copy Link

Asking price: $399K
Size: 4 bedroom, 2 bath, 1356sf, 0.18 acre
The skinny: This would be a great buy for an investor, as it’s a legal two-family containing two apartments, each with two bedrooms and a bath. There’s also deeded water access to North Sea Harbor.

Southampton

Copy Link

Asking price: $4.995M
Size: 6 bedrooms, 3 baths, 3000sf on 1 acre
The skinny: This compound is the last piece of the Phillips farm, owned by the family since 1670. In the Southampton estate section, the property offers a main house built in 1899, a guest cottage with two bedrooms and one full bath, which used to be an estate boathouse on Lake Agawam, a pool house with a studio apartment, a garage, barn and shed.

Water Mill

Copy Link

Asking price: $575K
Size: 3 bedroom, 2 bath, 1255sf, 0.55 acre
The skinny: Set on over a half acre in the quiet Water Mill countryside, this house is ripe for expansion and renovation. Add a pool, too, as there’s plenty of room. The location makes for easy access to ocean or bay beaches as well as Water Mill, Bridgehampton, and Sag Harbor towns.

Sagaponack

Copy Link

Asking price: $5.75M
Size: 4 bedroom, 3 bath, 1800sf, 1.03 acre
The skinny: This house needs some work to bring it out of the swinging 60s. If you add a second story, you can gain views of Sagg Pond; as it is, there’s a pool, garage, and decking to listen to the close-by ocean.

Asking price: $365K
Size: 2 bedroom, 1 bath, 620sf, 0.11 acre
The skinny: A tiny cottage on a tiny plot: but the price is tiny, too. In the Pine Neck community, it’s easy walking distance to the beach and just a few minutes to the shops and restaurants of Sag Harbor.

East Hampton Northwest

Copy Link

Asking price: $659K
Size: 2 bedroom, 2 bath, 1400sf, 0.63 acre
The skinny: This 60s house, surrounded by tall trees, is close to the harbor and town. There’s a freeform pool in the peaceful backyard.

East Hampton

Copy Link

Asking price: $500K
Size: 3 bedroom, 1 bath, 1100sf, 0.3 acre
The skinny: This cute 60s ranch is close to town and in the desirable school district. The yard has plenty of room for a pool and the existing garage could be used as a pool house.

Amagansett Dunes

Copy Link

Asking price: $4.9M
Size: 3 bedroom, 3.5 bath, 1800sf, 0.74 acre
The skinny: This contemporary beach house is begging to be brought into the 21st century. There is a pool and deeded beach access, along with ocean views.

Montauk

Copy Link

Asking price: $650K
Size: 1 bedroom, 1 bath, 592sf, 0.4 acre
The skinny: Clutter? What clutter? This cute, tiny, cottage needs updating, but location is great: directly across from Fort Pond, with town, beach, jitney, and LIRR within walking distance.

Shinnecock

Asking price: $1.6M
Size: 4 bedroom, 3 bath, 3730sf, 0.4 acre
The skinny: This spacious house is suffering from a bad case of the 1990s. Of course, the real star here is the 148 feet of frontage on the Great Peconic Bay. It’s all about the views.

North Sea

Asking price: $399K
Size: 4 bedroom, 2 bath, 1356sf, 0.18 acre
The skinny: This would be a great buy for an investor, as it’s a legal two-family containing two apartments, each with two bedrooms and a bath. There’s also deeded water access to North Sea Harbor.

Southampton

Asking price: $4.995M
Size: 6 bedrooms, 3 baths, 3000sf on 1 acre
The skinny: This compound is the last piece of the Phillips farm, owned by the family since 1670. In the Southampton estate section, the property offers a main house built in 1899, a guest cottage with two bedrooms and one full bath, which used to be an estate boathouse on Lake Agawam, a pool house with a studio apartment, a garage, barn and shed.

Water Mill

Asking price: $575K
Size: 3 bedroom, 2 bath, 1255sf, 0.55 acre
The skinny: Set on over a half acre in the quiet Water Mill countryside, this house is ripe for expansion and renovation. Add a pool, too, as there’s plenty of room. The location makes for easy access to ocean or bay beaches as well as Water Mill, Bridgehampton, and Sag Harbor towns.

Sagaponack

Asking price: $5.75M
Size: 4 bedroom, 3 bath, 1800sf, 1.03 acre
The skinny: This house needs some work to bring it out of the swinging 60s. If you add a second story, you can gain views of Sagg Pond; as it is, there’s a pool, garage, and decking to listen to the close-by ocean.

Noyack

Asking price: $365K
Size: 2 bedroom, 1 bath, 620sf, 0.11 acre
The skinny: A tiny cottage on a tiny plot: but the price is tiny, too. In the Pine Neck community, it’s easy walking distance to the beach and just a few minutes to the shops and restaurants of Sag Harbor.

East Hampton Northwest

Asking price: $659K
Size: 2 bedroom, 2 bath, 1400sf, 0.63 acre
The skinny: This 60s house, surrounded by tall trees, is close to the harbor and town. There’s a freeform pool in the peaceful backyard.

East Hampton

Asking price: $500K
Size: 3 bedroom, 1 bath, 1100sf, 0.3 acre
The skinny: This cute 60s ranch is close to town and in the desirable school district. The yard has plenty of room for a pool and the existing garage could be used as a pool house.

Amagansett Dunes

Asking price: $4.9M
Size: 3 bedroom, 3.5 bath, 1800sf, 0.74 acre
The skinny: This contemporary beach house is begging to be brought into the 21st century. There is a pool and deeded beach access, along with ocean views.

Montauk

Asking price: $650K
Size: 1 bedroom, 1 bath, 592sf, 0.4 acre
The skinny: Clutter? What clutter? This cute, tiny, cottage needs updating, but location is great: directly across from Fort Pond, with town, beach, jitney, and LIRR within walking distance.