clock menu more-arrow no yes
Photo courtesy of Corcoran

What $5M buys you in Bridgehampton right now

All of these houses are 6,000 square feet or bigger

View as Map

Welcome to Curbed Comparisons, a column that explores what one can buy or rent for a certain price in the Hamptons.

Today’s price: $5 million in Bridgehampton

Read More

1. 15 Fair Hills Lane: $5.25M

Copy Link
15 Fair Hills Ln
Bridgehampton, NY 11932

Interestingly, this north-of-the-highway home is the furthest from the ocean, the most expensive, and the smallest that we’re featuring. Standing a still sizable 5,896 square feet, the newly built home hosts eight bedrooms and seven bathrooms. It also has an additional 2,400 square feet on the finished lower level, a movie theater, home gym, sun room, and smart home technology.

The farmhouse is sited on 1.11 acres of land, and outside, there’s a heated gunite pool and spa, as well as bluestone patios.

Photo courtesy of Bespoke

2. 23 Kellis Way: $4.995M

Copy Link
23 Kellis Way
Water Mill, NY 11976

This massive 9,200-square-foot home is the largest Bridgehampton home that we’re featuring, sited just south of the highway. Inside, there are seven bedrooms and eight bathrooms, a fireplace in the living room, an eat-in kitchen, and a screened-in patio.

On nearly 4 acres of land, the exterior offers mahogany and stone patios, a heated gunite pool and spa, and direct waterfront access onto Kellis Pond.

Photo courtesy of Corcoran

3. 555 Paul’s Lane: $4.995M

Copy Link
555 Pauls Ln
Peconic, NY 11958

The 6,000-square-foot, five-bedroom, six-bath home at 555 Paul’s Lane is sited on nearly a full acre of land, sited south of the highway off Ocean Road. Inside, there’s an entry foyer, an eat-in kitchen, and doors that lead out to the large second-floor deck that overlooks the property.

Outside, there are brick terraces, a pool, pool house with full bathroom and a basement, gardens, a basketball court, a two-car garage, and an outdoor shower.

Photo courtesy of Saunders

4. 281 Narrow Lane: $4.85

Copy Link
281 Narrow Ln
Bridgehampton, NY 11932

The least expensive home that we’re featuring is a farmhouse built in 2013 with 7,000 square feet on 1.8 acres. There are five bedrooms and four and a half bathrooms inside, as well as an open floorplan, wide plank rough hewn oak flooring, a two-story fireplace, and radiant heated floors in the kitchen.

Meanwhile, the exterior of this home offers a heated gunite saltwater pool and bluestone patios,

Photo courtesy of Brown Harris Stevens

Loading comments...

1. 15 Fair Hills Lane: $5.25M

15 Fair Hills Ln, Bridgehampton, NY 11932
Photo courtesy of Bespoke

Interestingly, this north-of-the-highway home is the furthest from the ocean, the most expensive, and the smallest that we’re featuring. Standing a still sizable 5,896 square feet, the newly built home hosts eight bedrooms and seven bathrooms. It also has an additional 2,400 square feet on the finished lower level, a movie theater, home gym, sun room, and smart home technology.

The farmhouse is sited on 1.11 acres of land, and outside, there’s a heated gunite pool and spa, as well as bluestone patios.

15 Fair Hills Ln
Bridgehampton, NY 11932

2. 23 Kellis Way: $4.995M

23 Kellis Way, Water Mill, NY 11976
Photo courtesy of Corcoran

This massive 9,200-square-foot home is the largest Bridgehampton home that we’re featuring, sited just south of the highway. Inside, there are seven bedrooms and eight bathrooms, a fireplace in the living room, an eat-in kitchen, and a screened-in patio.

On nearly 4 acres of land, the exterior offers mahogany and stone patios, a heated gunite pool and spa, and direct waterfront access onto Kellis Pond.

23 Kellis Way
Water Mill, NY 11976

3. 555 Paul’s Lane: $4.995M

555 Pauls Ln, Peconic, NY 11958
Photo courtesy of Saunders

The 6,000-square-foot, five-bedroom, six-bath home at 555 Paul’s Lane is sited on nearly a full acre of land, sited south of the highway off Ocean Road. Inside, there’s an entry foyer, an eat-in kitchen, and doors that lead out to the large second-floor deck that overlooks the property.

Outside, there are brick terraces, a pool, pool house with full bathroom and a basement, gardens, a basketball court, a two-car garage, and an outdoor shower.

555 Pauls Ln
Peconic, NY 11958

4. 281 Narrow Lane: $4.85

281 Narrow Ln, Bridgehampton, NY 11932
Photo courtesy of Brown Harris Stevens

The least expensive home that we’re featuring is a farmhouse built in 2013 with 7,000 square feet on 1.8 acres. There are five bedrooms and four and a half bathrooms inside, as well as an open floorplan, wide plank rough hewn oak flooring, a two-story fireplace, and radiant heated floors in the kitchen.

Meanwhile, the exterior of this home offers a heated gunite saltwater pool and bluestone patios,

281 Narrow Ln
Bridgehampton, NY 11932