Pricespotter
Big Reveal: $10.7M for a waterfront modern in North Haven
The newly-constructed modern home has 4,500 square feet of space with four bedrooms, five full bathrooms, and one half-bathroom.
How much for a four-bedroom waterfront modern in North Haven?
We love the unique features that are scattered throughout the space—in particular, the rounded floating staircase and sunken area of the living room caught our eye.
Big Reveal: $1.099M for a 1980 East Hampton contemporary style home
Admittedly, it could use some updates. Some of our readers didn’t like the wall colors in the home, but wall color is an easy thing to change. What we like about this home is that it has the bare bones that will make updates easy.
How much for a 1980 contemporary style home in East Hampton?
We’re loving the countertop pass-through window between the kitchen and living room, the muted mint wall colors, and the sunny foyer with skylights.
Big Reveal: $1.65M for a renovated North Haven home with an attached greenhouse
Since it’s been in the hands of the current owners, renovations have been completed throughout the home, originally built in 1980—including new kitchen cabinets installed in a fantastic candy apple red.
How much for a turnkey North Haven home with an attached greenhouse?
Right now, the addition off the living space is staged as a sunroom, but it can be used as a proper greenhouse.
Big Reveal: $11.5M for an oceanfront Water Mill home with views of Mecox Bay
Most of our readers guessed that the beach house was listed for between $12 million and $15 million. Located at 1341 Flying Point Road, the property is actually asking $11.5 million.
How much for an oceanfront Water Mill home with views of Mecox Bay?
The master bathroom features a dual vanity, massive soaking tub with ocean views, and French doors leading to what looks like a private deck.
Big Reveal: $3.295M for a renovated Water Mill cottage sitting south of the highway
The home last sold in 2016 for $2,275,000. Most of our readers—about 42 percent—guessed the home was currently asking between $2 million and $3 million.
How much for a renovated Water Mill cottage sitting south of the highway?
Originally built in 1966, the home has been recently renovated to bring it up to date with new flooring, a new roof, and a fresh coat of paint.
How much for a Water Mill home situated next to over 100 acres of reserve?
The property itself is just a half-acre
Big Reveal: $5.75M for a newly built Bridgehampton modern
The highest poll categories were tied. Most people guessed the correct range of between $5 million and $6 million, but the same amount of readers—23 percent—also guessed that the home was asking over $8 million.
How much for a newly built Bridgehampton modern with 7,000 square feet?
The home has seven bedrooms, eight full bathrooms, and one half bathroom in 7,000 square feet, and sits on over three acres of land on a flag lot.
Big Reveal: $30M for an oceanfront spec house in Sagaponack
Most of our readers thought it was asking between $20M and $25M
How much for a 5,200-square-foot oceanfront spec house in Sagaponack?
The property last sold for $12 million in 2015. What do you think the asking price is now?
Big Reveal: $2.4M for an updated waterfront Hampton Bays home with a private beach
The asking price on this 2,700-square-foot home is $2,395,000—but most of our readers guessed that it was between $3 and $5 million.
How much for an updated ’60s Hampton Bays home with a private beach?
Can you guess the asking price?
Big Reveal: $5.5M for a North Haven postmodern with water views
Most people guessed this week’s PriceSpotter accurately, though almost the same amount of people guessed it was asking higher.
How much for a North Haven postmodern with water views?
The postmodern construction was built in 1989, designed to take advantage of the water views from every room in the house.
Big Reveal: $12M for a Southampton village manse on Herrick Road
Some people high-balled it, thinking it was over $13 million, and even one person thought it was over $16 million.
How much for a century-old Southampton village manse with pool and tennis?
The property features high hedges for privacy, an outdoor kitchen, bluestone patios, pool house, heated pool, and Har-Tru tennis court.
How much for a new 4,000-square-foot contemporary in Amagansett?
Inside, there are floor-to-ceiling glass windows, laminate floors, marble kitchen counter tops, and a finished lower level.
Big Reveal: $2.125 for a Hither Woods home with indoor pool in Montauk
One of our readers guessed the property was listed for $1.99 million—and they weren’t far off. The asking price is $2,125,000.
How much for a Hither Woods shingle style home with an indoor pool in Montauk?
While it’s south of the highway, it’s not waterfront nor are there water views.
Big Reveal: $30M for the Water Mill new construction on 13 acres
The outdoor terraces on both the first and second levels face out to Mecox Bay, and from the second level one can see the ocean.
How much for a 10,000-square-foot new build on 13 waterfront acres in Water Mill?
This new build in Water Mill has over 13 acres of waterfront land on Mecox Bay, plus ocean views from upstairs.
Big Reveal: $3.4M for this eight-bedroom Georgica home
Built in 2002, the 6,000-square-foot home sits on 1.1 acres and has five and a half bathrooms, separate staff quarters, an expansive master wing, a common balcony, covered porches, and a heated gunite pool.
How much for this eight-bedroom Georgica home?
Can you guess the asking price?
Big reveal: how much for a waterfront cottage on Three Mile Harbor?
Close but no cigar this week. (Cigars ain’t free, people.) We acknowledge this one was a little tougher this week.
How much for a waterfront cottage on Three Mile Harbor?
This waterfront property isn’t huge, but everything in it is nicely done and high end. Walls of glass make the most of the harborfront view.
Big reveal: how much for an East Hampton cottage and barn?
This property offers quite a bit, we think, with a main house, barn (guest house), pool and pool house. Will someone snap it up soon?
How much for an East Hampton cottage and barn?
This 1860 gambrel comes complete with a renovated barn, a pool, and a pool house on its spacious, attractive grounds.
Big reveal: how much for a stunning new build Bates Masi in Sagaponack?
Too easy this week: the actual price was the number one guess. Apparently all commenters were stunned by the listing’s beauty into silence.
How much for a stunning new build Bates Masi in Sagaponack?
This gorgeous house doesn’t exist yet, but it’s amazing. There are separate buildings connected by glass bridges for the living areas and bedrooms.
Big reveal: how much for a colorful contemporary artist’s home in East Hampton?
This very colorful house is the home and studio of artist Ernst Lurker. It reminded one commenter of the house from the movie Ruthless People.
How much for a colorful contemporary artist’s home in East Hampton?
Are you a collector of Memphis furniture? Swatch watches? Then this is your house! It’s a fun property.
Big reveal: how much for an architect-designed contemporary in East Hampton’s Northwest?
This 80s contemporary by Bruce Nagel is on prestigious Bull Path. Most of you thought the asking price was higher than it is.
How much for an architect-designed contemporary in East Hampton’s Northwest?
A timeless, attractive contemporary by Bruce Nagel