Pricespotter
Big Reveal: $200K to rent this restored Amagansett farmhouse all summer
About a third of our readers guessed correctly.
How much to rent a restored farmhouse in Amagansett this summer?
Can you guess this week’s PriceSpotter?
Big Reveal: $125K for a Montauk summer rental with golf course views
About a third of our readers were correct!
How much for this Montauk Downs summer rental?
Can you guess this week’s PriceSpotter?
Big Reveal: $95K to rent this North Haven traditional with bay access for the summer
Outside, the future tenants will enjoy a heated gunite pool and access to Sag Harbor Bay.
How much to rent a North Haven traditional with bay access for the summer?
Can you guess this week’s PriceSpotter?
Big Reveal: $180K to rent this Southampton bayview contemporary
It has water views out to Shinnecock Bay
How much to rent a renovated bayview contemporary in Southampton this summer?
Can you guess this week’s PriceSpotter?
Big Reveal: $3.6M for this East Hampton contemporary with a pool and tennis
About a third of our readers guessed correctly that the home was asking between $3 million and $4 million.
How much for this East Hampton contemporary with a pool and tennis?
Can you guess this week’s PriceSpotter?
Big Reveal: $35K to rent this Sag Harbor ranch from August to Labor Day
About half our readers were right!
How much to rent a bright Sag Harbor ranch from August to Labor Day?
The shingled home features large windows that bring in lots of light, hardwood floors, and clean, crisp white walls throughout.
Big Reveal: $225K to rent a Wainscott bungalow on Georgica Pond for the summer
Located at 15 Association Road, the home is part of the Georgica Association, affording residents access to community tennis courts and a private beach.
How much to rent a Wainscott bungalow on Georgica Pond for the summer?
Can you guess this week’s PriceSpotter?
Big Reveal: $6.995M for a restored upside-down beach house in Montauk
Most readers were spot-on
How much for a restored upside-down beach house in Montauk?
Located south of the highway, this contemporary style home is sited near Shadmoor State Park—a convenient distance between Ditch Plains Beach and Montauk’s business district.
Big Reveal: $275K for a Bridgehampton summer rental on Kellis Pond
Most readers overshot it by just a bit
How much for a Bridgehampton summer rental on Kellis Pond?
Can you guess this week’s PriceSpotter?
Big Reveal: $160K to rent a renovated barn in Sagaponack for the summer
Most readers were close, but low-balled it
How much to rent a renovated barn in Sagaponack for the summer?
Though the property is technically south of the highway, it’s very close to the highway—but, it’s set back on a long driveway and hedged for privacy.
Big Reveal: $3.595M for a modern barn in East Hampton
Most readers were correct!
How much for a modern, six-bedroom barn in East Hampton?
Can you guess this week’s PriceSpotter?
Big Reveal: $2.595M for a Sag Harbor village traditional on a half-acre
Most readers thought it was listed between $3M and $4M
How much for a Sag Harbor village traditional on a half-acre?
This traditional style home, however, was built in 2014—and this week, we’re having readers guess the asking price of the estate.
Big Reveal: $4.75M for a privately-situated Amagansett home on two acres
Most readers thought it was between $6M and $7M
How much for a private Amagansett home on two acres?
Can you guess this week’s PriceSpotter?
Big Reveal: $3.49M for an East Hampton smart home with a live organic wall
Most readers thought it was over $4M
Big Reveal: $5.3M for a renovated Sag Harbor village home from 1830
French doors lead to the exterior, which is host to separate studio cottage with a full bathroom, a heated saltwater pool, a sunbed on the lounging area, and an outdoor shower.
How much for a renovated Sag Harbor village home from 1830?
What do you think it’s listed for?
Big Reveal: $12.9M for a French-style manor in Southampton
Most readers guessed it was listed between $10 million and $12 million
How much for a French-style manor in Southampton’s estate section?
Built in 2007, the home has been completely renovated and currently features an antique imported front door, a marble foyer, and fireplaces in both the living room and formal dining room.
Big Reveal: $3.995M for a Mediterranean-style Southampton home
The nearly two-acre property is on a privately situated road, located about three miles north of Southampton village.
How much for a Mediterranean-style estate in Southampton?
Can you guess this week’s PriceSpotter?
Big Reveal: $2.195M for a private turnkey home in East Hampton
Most of our readers—44 percent—guessed that it was listed for between $2 million and $3 million, making most of our readers correct!
How much for a privately situated turnkey home in East Hampton?
Can you guess this week’s PriceSpotter?
Big Reveal: $11.2M for a Sagaponack manse next to a nature reserve
Most readers guessed it was listed for a bit lower
How much for a six-bedroom Sagaponack manse adjacent to a nature reserve?
Located south of the highway, the property is about a mile from the ocean at Peter’s Pond, and about two miles from Wölffer Estate Vineyards.