clock menu more-arrow no yes

Pricespotter

Big reveal: $1.6M for a newly built contemporary in Hampton Bays

Features include an open floorplan between the living and dining spaces, walls of glass, a second-story terrace, and a waterview rooftop deck.

How much for a brand new, light-filled contemporary in Hampton Bays?

Can you guess this week’s PriceSpotter?

Big reveal: $1.825M for an Amagansett beach cottage right near the ocean

The home is just a 10-minute drive from Montauk, and about the same distance from Amagansett’s Main Street shops and restaurants.

How much for a beach cottage in Amagansett right near the ocean?

Try and guess this week’s PriceSpotter

Big reveal: $3M for a bright Sag Harbor cottage with white interiors

The like-new cottage was "virtually re-built from the ground up" according to the listing, so there was an existing home before the total renovation.

How much for a bright cottage with white interiors in Sag Harbor?

Can you guess this week’s PriceSpotter?

Big reveal: $5M for a renovated traditional in Bridgehampton

The property last sold in 2011 for $2 million, and about a third of our readers thought that it was still asking under $3.5 million after the renovations that brought the Bridgehampton home up to date.

Big reveal: $1.35M for a Queen Anne bed and breakfast in Greenport

Sited at 151 Bay Avenue, the 19th century home offers 5,000 square feet of living space, four bedrooms, four bathrooms, a wraparound front porch, and a three-story turret with bay windows.

How much for a Queen Anne Victorian bed and breakfast from 1880 in Greenport?

Can you guess this week’s PriceSpotter?

Big reveal: $7.5M for a renovated home in south-of-the-highway Sagaponack

What do you think of the price?

How much for a renovated contemporary home in south-of-the-highway Sagaponack?

We’re particularly fond of the futuristic floating glass staircase, hardwood floors found throughout, and the massive eat-in kitchen with stainless steel appliances and clean white cabinetry.

Big reveal: $5.7M for an 1802 farmhouse and entertainment barn in Amagansett

Built in 1802, the 3,000-square-foot home has four bedrooms and three bathrooms, period details throughout, a country kitchen, wood beamed ceilings in the living room, and a master suite.

How much for a farmhouse from 1802 and an entertainment barn in Amagansett?

Can you guess this week’s PriceSpotter?

Big reveal: $1.595M for a compact, designer-owned Springs cottage

Outside, new homeowners will arrive at the hedged 0.91-acre property through a gated entry and approach the cottage. Unfortunately the property doesn’t have a pool, but there is a meditation gazebo and lounging and dining space in the backyard.

How much for a compact, designer-owned Springs cottage?

Outside, there isn’t a pool—but there’s plenty of space for one on the 0.91-acre property. New homeowners will enjoy the lounging space and meditation gazebo.

How much for a tiny, renovated Sag Harbor cottage?

Can you guess this week’s PriceSpotter?

Big reveal: $9.5M for a light-filled Amagansett oceanfront home on 2 acres

Most readers guessed that this oceanfront Amagansett home set on 2 acres of land was listed somewhere between $9 million and $10 million. On the market for $9.5 million, these readers are correct.

How much for a light-filled Amagansett oceanfront on 2 acres?

Can you guess this week’s PriceSpotter?

Big Reveal: $1.32M for a historic Quogue Colonial from 1796

Originally built in 1796 and then later expanded in the early 1800s, the nearly 4,000-square-foot home sits on 1.25 acres of land.

How much for a historic Quogue Colonial from 1796?

Originally built in 1796 and then later expanded in the 1800s, this classic Colonial style home in Quogue has recently come on the market—so this week, we’re having readers guess its asking price.

Big Reveal: $3.7M for an oceanfront Westhampton home on a quarter acre

We’re thinking that the small, quarter-acre property is the reason that this Dune Road home is asking just $3.7 million. You almost never see a price that low for an oceanfront home in the Hamptons—especially when the house isn’t a teardown.

How much for an oceanfront home in Westhampton on a quarter acre?

Can you guess this week’s PriceSpotter?

Big Reveal: $21M for designer Tomas Maier’s oceanfront Montauk home

The home currently belongs to designer Tomas Maier, the former creative director at the Italian high fashion brand, Bottega Veneta, where he filled the position from 2001 up until June of 2018.

How much for an oceanfront modern home in Montauk?

Can you guess this week’s PriceSpotter?

Big Reveal: $10.75M for a waterview compound in Montauk near the ocean

A heated gunite pool and spa, 2,000 square feet of exterior decking, and a pool house with a half-bathroom, wet bar, and outdoor shower are all shared between the main house and the guest house.

How much for an oceanview compound in Montauk?

Can you guess this week’s PriceSpotter?

Big Reveal: $1.495M for a brand new, energy efficient home in Springs

Sliding glass doors lead outside, where one will find a 700-square-foot mahogany deck, a saltwater heated pool, and hedged gardens.

How much for a brand new, energy efficient home in Springs?

Last year, the property sold for $350,000—but since there’s now a newly built house on the property, we’re going to start the guessing at $1 million.

Big Reveal: $3.3M for a sunny bayfront beach house in Springs

The beachfront property last sold in 2014 for $1,537,500—do you think it’s fairly priced this time around on the market?

How much for a sunny waterfront beach house in Springs?

Big Reveal: $2.999M for a waterfront compound in Hampton Bays

Standing 2,900 square feet, the main house on this waterfront property has four bedrooms, three full bathrooms, one half-bathroom, and an open floorplan on the second level where the living and dining rooms are situated.

How much for a bayfront compound in Hampton Bays?

The property is zoned as residential with business, which allows for some income potential. There are two additional cottages on the property for extra living or work space.

Big Reveal: $29.95M for a newly built waterfront modern in Water Mill

The fourth level accessed by elevator is the rooftop waterview terrace, where the future homeowner will look out to both Mecox Bay and the Atlantic Ocean.

Big Reveal: $1.275M for a charming pondfront cottage in Southampton

Unfortunately the property doesn’t have enough space for a pool, but there are plenty of people who would take private pond frontage over a pool any day.

How much for a tiny, pondfront cottage in Southampton with lots of charm?

This week, we’re having our readers guess the asking price of the adorable abode, standing just 1,000 square feet in size with two bedrooms and two full bathrooms.

Big Reveal: $1.75M for an 18th century equestrian farm in Springs

About a third of readers were correct

How much for an 18th century equestrian farm in Springs?

Can you guess this week’s PriceSpotter?

Big Reveal: $9.95M for a creekfront home in Southampton’s estate section

One commenter was close to getting it right

How much for a creekfront home in Southampton’s estate section?

Can you guess this week’s PriceSpotter?