clock menu more-arrow no yes

Pricespotter

How much for this brand new Bridgehampton home near the village?

This week, we’re having readers guess the asking price of this brand new shingled traditional in north-of-the-highway Bridgehampton, located in a cul-de-sac.

Big reveal: $3.495M for this charming cottage in East Hampton village

Known as the Bee Cottage, local artist Stephanie Clark purchased the property in September of 2017 for $2,995,000 and redesigned the house, which was originally built in 1929.

How much for this charming East Hampton village cottage from 1929?

Can you guess this week’s PriceSpotter?

Big reveal: $1.595M for a renovated three-level home in Northwest Woods

Interiors include four bedrooms, four and a half bathrooms, wood floors, a fireplace in the living room, and a brand new kitchen with a large center island. Downstairs, a finished lower level has direct access outside and to the attached two-car garage.

How much for this renovated three-level home in East Hampton’s Northwest Woods?

Can you guess the asking price?

Big reveal: $2.995M for this bayview house in Amagansett

Built in 1989, there have been some recent updates, but we’re thinking that the new owners will still want to do some renovations here and there, like in the kitchen.

How much for this bayview house in north-of-the-highway Amagansett?

This week’s PriceSpotter is an Amagansett home, originally built in 1989. Possibly the most desirable feature of this house is the water views over Napeague Bay from the covered porch outside.

Big reveal: $695K for a compact beach house in the Northwest Woods

Standing a modest 1,000 square feet in size, there’s only three bedrooms and one bathroom inside—so we’re thinking that the new owners are going to want to add another bathroom.

How much for this compact house near Three Mile Harbor in Springs?

Features include high cathedral ceilings, a wood-burning fireplace, and a wall of windows with distant water views of a creek that leads into the harbor.

Big reveal: $3.99M for a waterfront house in Westhampton with a pool and tennis

After coming on the market earlier this week, the property is listed for $3,995,000. We started the poll at $4.65 million because that’s what it sold for back in 2007.

How much for a waterfront house in Westhampton with a pool and tennis?

Let’s see if you can guess this week’s PriceSpotter

How much for a renovated waterfront house with a dock in Sag Harbor?

Can you guess this week’s PriceSpotter?

Big reveal: $2.37M for a tiny oceanview cottage in Montauk

Some work will need to be done to bring the house up to date, and it may be a bit small for some people’s taste, but the 0.69-acre property is in a desirable south-of-the-highway Hither Hills location.

How much for this tiny 900 sq. ft. oceanview cottage in Montauk?

Can you guess this week’s PriceSpotter?

Big reveal: $9.85M for a shingled Gambrel in Bridgehampton

It has a pool and tennis court on 2 acres

How much for a shingled Gambrel in north-of-the-highway Bridgehampton?

The finished lower level—which adds another almost 4,000 square feet to the house’s footprint—hosts a wine cellar, a gym, a sauna, a media room, and an entertaining area with a bar and fireplace.

Big reveal: $6.495M for an ivy-covered Southampton village home

The 4,500-square-foot ivy-covered house includes six bedrooms and five and a half bathrooms on 1.5 acres of land just moments from village shops and restaurants.

How much for an ivy-covered house with pool and tennis in Southampton village?

The builder’s own home has 4,500-square-foot home has six bedrooms and five bathrooms, coffered ceilings, a large eat-in kitchen, and a master suite with radiant heated floors in the bathroom. Other features include hardwood flo

Big reveal: how much for a Water Mill estate with spa?

The number one answer this week was $3M more than the actual price. Bargain! And despite naysayers, this spa is a winner.

How much to rent Elie Tahari’s oceanfront Sagaponack home?

There’s a huge beamed great room with ocean view, a lovely dining pergola, a long pool surrounded by olive trees, and even a basketball half-court.

Big reveal: how much to rent Elie Tahari’s oceanfront Sagaponack home?

The place is gorgeous, if a bit quirky and designed basically for a single person. That dreamy pool would be a wonderful place to spend the summer.

Big reveal: $3.4M for this shingled north-of-the-highway East Hampton house

About 26 percent of readers correctly guessed that it was asking somewhere between $3 million and $3.5 million.

How much for a shingled north-of-the-highway house in East Hampton?

Can you guess this week’s PriceSpotter?

Big reveal: $1.295M for a tiny waterfront cottage in Lazy Point

What do you think of the price?

How much for a 900 sq. ft. waterfront cottage in Napeague?

Features include hardwood floors, stainless steel appliances in the updated kitchen, and French doors that lead to a waterview deck outside.

Big reveal: $995K for a renovated Montauk ranch

About 37 percent of votes went to the category between $1 million and $1.25 million, and some even guessed that it was over $1.5 million.

How much for a renovated ranch in Montauk?

Can you guess the asking price? Take our poll and tell us your thoughts in the comments.

Big reveal: $3.595M for a shingled ‘cottage’ in north Amagansett

A third of our readers were correct!

How much for a shingled ‘cottage’ in north-of-the-highway Amagansett?

The property is about 1 mile north of the Amagansett train station and about 2 miles from the ocean at the end of Atlantic Avenue.

Big reveal: $3.495M for a renovated creekfront home in Westhampton

Built in 2000, the 3,180-square-foot home offers hardwood floors throughout and a double-height waterview living room with a wall of windows.

How much for a renovated creekfront home in the Westhampton Dunes?

What do you think it’s listed for?

Big reveal: $4.995M for a brand new north-of-the-highway modern in Amagansett

Located at 21 Fresh Pond Road, the barn style home spans a comfortable 3,800 square feet in size on 1 acre of land.

How much for a newly built modern in north-of-the-highway Amagansett?

Can you guess the asking price?

Big reveal: $4.25M for a restored whaling captain’s home in Sag Harbor village

Inside the 2,780-square-foot home, there are five bedrooms, five and a half bathrooms, a gas fireplace, and period details throughout—including the original molding.

How much for this 19th century whaling captain’s home in Sag Harbor village?

Can you guess the asking price?

Big reveal: $2.995M for a shingled north Sagaponack home

55 percent of our readers were correct

How much for a shingled north-of-the-highway Sagaponack home?

In 2005, the property was purchased for $970,000 and the current home was completed two years after. Since the property now includes a home, we’re going to start the guessing at $1.5 million.

Big reveal: $2.975M for a modern barn style home in Water Mill

More than half of our readers cast their votes in the highest two categories—between $3 million and $3.5 million, and over $3.5 million. In 2008, the property sold for $2.5 million. Before that, it sold as an empty lot in 2004 for $425,000.

How much for this modern barn style home in Water Mill?

Built in 2006, the home sold in 2008 for $2.5 million, and now 10 years later it’s back on the market. Can you guess what the property is listed for?