, , NY
The house is in need of a renovation (it doesn’t look like it’s been touched since the ’60s), but we think that the midcentury time capsule would make a great fixer-upper project.
The 4.3-acre property has a 22-room inn, space for private events and weddings, a tennis court, and a restaurant
Considering the size of the house and the fact that it’s waterfront, the price doesn’t seem too bad—but the downside is that it’s only on a half-acre of land.
After five years and another price cut, the Victorian style home is listed for nearly half of its original ask: $4.9 million.
Let’s see what this budget gets you here
Located at 53 North Cartwright Road, the move-in ready home offers 2,000 square feet, four bedrooms, and two and a half bathrooms on almost a full acre of land.
The largest parcel currently available for sale on Shelter Island spans 20 acres—and it’s waterfront on West Neck Creek.
In 2005, the property sold for $1.57 million and the current house was finished three years later in 2008. Though it’s been available to rent in the past, this is the first time that it’s come on the sales market.
This gorgeous shingled farmhouse at 53 North Cartwright Road is just one example of the many great homes that are on the market for less than $1 million.
But the study only examined 20 destinations in New York State
Originally built in 1810, it’s the only surviving windmill from the North Fork