clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Big reveal: $2.37M for a tiny oceanview cottage in Montauk

New, 3 comments

Half of our readers thought it was listed for under $2M

Photo courtesy of Corcoran


What do you think this oceanview Montauk cottage is listed for?

This poll is closed

  • 50%
    Under $2M
    (33 votes)
  • 26%
    Between $2M and $2.25M
    (17 votes)
  • 13%
    Between $2.25M and $2.5M
    (9 votes)
  • 9%
    Over $2.5M
    (6 votes)
65 votes total Vote Now

Earlier this week, we asked our readers to try and guess the asking price of an oceanview cottage in Montauk just moments from the beach. Typically, our poll results are pretty split, but in this case more than half of the votes were in a single category.

Most of our readers thought that the 900-square-foot shingled house was on the market for under $2 million, but it’s actually listed for $2,375,000.

The two-bedroom, two-bath house has hardwood floors, a fireplace in the living room, and sliding glass doors off the master suite that lead out to an oceanview deck. Some work will need to be done to bring the house up to date, and it may be a bit small for some people’s taste, but the 0.69-acre property is in a desirable south-of-the-highway Hither Hills location. Homeowners will also have the benefit of being on a high elevation and will get deeded ocean beach access.

Sited at 20 Hamilton Drive, it would take just 3 minutes to walk to the ocean according to Google Maps.

Corcoran Group agent Helen Stubbmann represents the listing.

Photo courtesy of Corcoran
Photo courtesy of Corcoran
Photo courtesy of Corcoran
Photo courtesy of Corcoran
Photo courtesy of Corcoran

For tips and corrections, please email


, , NY 11954