clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

What $1M buys you on Shelter Island right now

New, 2 comments

Which one do you like the best?

Photo courtesy of Saunders

Welcome to Curbed Comparisons, a column that explores what one can buy or rent for a certain price in the Hamptons.

Today’s price: $1 million on Shelter Island.

24 Ram Island Road: $1.15M

24 Ram Island Road photos: Corcoran

Built in 1770, this cottage was built for a farmer and miller and has maintained its 18th century charm after renovations, which have included new windows, siding, roof, wiring, plumbing, and updates to the kitchen and bathrooms.

The 1,519-square-foot home has two bedrooms and two and a half bathrooms on 1.4 acres of land, which can accommodate an additional house and pool.

22 East Brander Parkway: $1.095M

22 E Brander Parkway photos: Saunders

This slightly larger 1,717-square-foot home has five bedrooms and three bathrooms—but it’s on a much smaller 0.32 acres of land. Built in 1937, the cape style home features a wood-burning fireplace, a kitchen with a center island, and a master suite with water views on the second level. There’s also a finished lower level with a playroom, workshop, and laundry room.

2 West Neck Road: $999K

In 2,522 square feet, this shingled farmhouse has four bedrooms and two and a half bathrooms, a front foyer, a fireplace in the living room, and a country kitchen with a breakfast area.

The master suite hosts a spa-like bathroom with a soaking tub and frameless glass shower, while the other three bedrooms can be found on the second floor. The library features French doors that lead outside, where one will find a pool, gardens, and custom lattice fencing.

166 North Ferry Road: $999K

166 North Ferry Road: Saunders

The largest house features has a decent 2,880 square feet and a full nine bedrooms, but only three and a half bathrooms. Built in 1850, the 19th century traditional—dubbed the Bowditch House—was originally a bed and breakfast.

Interiors include a country kitchen, a butler’s pantry, a dining room, and access to the outdoor entertainment deck, gardens, and pool.


Which Shelter Island home for around $1M do you like the best?

This poll is closed

  • 21%
    24 Ram Island Road: $1.15M
    (16 votes)
  • 5%
    22 Brander Parkway: $1.095M
    (4 votes)
  • 18%
    2 West Neck Road: $999K
    (14 votes)
  • 55%
    166 North Ferry Road: $999K
    (42 votes)
76 votes total Vote Now