clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

What $5M buys you in Water Mill right now

Which one would you want to purchase?

Photo courtesy of Sotheby’s

Welcome to Curbed Comparisons, a column that explores what one can buy or rent for a certain price in the Hamptons.

Today’s price: $5 million in Water Mill.

426 Ocean Road: $4.95M

426 Ocean Road: Photos courtesy of Saunders

The most expensive house on our list stands 4,000 square feet and is on the largest plot of the homes that we’re featuring—a decent 1.4 acres. The restored barn has four bedrooms and three bathrooms, an open floorplan, high ceilings, floor-to-ceiling windows, glass doors, and a farmhouse kitchen.

Outside, there’s a heated gunite pool and a bluestone patio.

495 Scuttle Hole Road: $4.85M

Photo courtesy of Sotheby’s

495 Scuttle Hole Road: Photos courtesy of Sotheby’s

This newly-built, custom home in north-of-the-highway Water Mill stands 5,900 square feet on a full acre of land—making it the largest house that we’re featuring, but the one furthest from the ocean. There are six bedrooms and eight bathrooms inside, as well as an open floorplan, a fireplace in the living room, and a butler’s pantry off the kitchen.

Outside, one will find a gunite pool and spa, a pool house with a bathroom and wet bar, and views of the nearby 47-acre nature reserve.

857 Ocean Road: $4.395M

857 Ocean Road: Photos courtesy of Douglas Elliman

The smallest house on our list is 2,000 square feet in size—but it’s also on nearly a full acre of land, and it’s the closest one to the ocean. In fact, it’s just one mile—or a 20-minute walk—from Ocean Road Beach.

There are five bedrooms and four bathrooms inside, a three-car garage, decking and a gunite pool, and room for expansion.


Which Bridgehampton home would you want to buy for under $5M?

This poll is closed

  • 12%
    426 Ocean Road: $4.95M
    (9 votes)
  • 56%
    495 Scuttle Hole Road: $4.85M
    (41 votes)
  • 30%
    857 Ocean Road: $4.395M
    (22 votes)
72 votes total Vote Now

The Hamptons

, , NY

Ocean Road Beach

1251 Ocean Road, , NY 11962

Ocean Road

Ocean Road, , NY