clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

What $3M buys you in Sag Harbor village right now

New, 1 comment

Curbed Comparisons takes a look at Sag Harbor village

Sotheby’s International Realty

Welcome to Curbed Comparisons, a column that explores what one can buy or rent for a certain price in the Hamptons.

Today’s price: $3 million in Sag Harbor village.

11 Henry Street: $2.875M

11 Henry Street: Corcoran

This 1830 Greek Revival style home is in need of some tender love and care, so we thought having a fixer-upper on the list would be a good option to feature for those who want to take on a project and make it their own. This 19th century historic home has 3,600 square feet of space, four bedrooms, and three bathrooms on 0.22 acres of land.

The listing claims that it was “once the first Presbyterian parsonage,” with features like pocket doors, hardwood floors, a spacious eat-in kitchen with a fireplace, and French doors off the first-level guest bedroom. Original features like the staircase and railings can be found throughout.

233 Madison Street: $2.795M

233 Madison Street: Brown Harris Stevens

Though this home was built back in 1840, the home has been totally modernized and brought into the 21st century. The 2,300-square-foot home has four bedrooms and three bathrooms, and a wood-burning fireplace in the double-height great room.

Outside, there’s a stone patio and a pool on 0.21 cares of land.

31 Archibald Way: $2.75M

31 Archibald Way: Brown Harris Stevens

Of the homes featured, this one is the furthest from village shops and restaurants—but it’s right across the street from Mashashimuet Park. In 3,150 square feet, there are four bedrooms and five bathrooms set out with an open floorplan and a finished lower level. Built in 1991, the home features stainless steel appliances in the kitchen, radiant heated floors and a heated towel rack in the master bathroom, and contemporary fixtures.

The half-acre property is surrounded by two reserves for privacy and has a heated saltwater gunite pool outdoors.

268 Main Street: $2.595M

This totally updated home from 1900 on Main Street has 2,900 square feet of living space, four bedrooms, and three and a half bathrooms on a quarter acre of land. Features include a two-story great room, a chef’s kitchen, and a wood-paneled library.

Outside, there’s a white picket fence (cute!) and a pool house with a kitchen and full bathroom, while the finished lower level offers a guest bedroom and bathroom, plus a laundry and media room.


Which Sag Harbor village home would you want to purchase for under $3M?

This poll is closed

  • 22%
    11 Henry Street: $2.875M
    (14 votes)
  • 14%
    233 Madison Street: $2.795M
    (9 votes)
  • 11%
    31 Archibald Way: $2.75M
    (7 votes)
  • 52%
    268 Main Street: $2.595M
    (33 votes)
63 votes total Vote Now

Sag Harbor

, , NY 11963

The Hamptons

, , NY

Main Street

Main Street, Queens, NY

Mashashimuet Park

, , NY 11963