Welcome to Curbed Comparisons, a column that explores what one can buy or rent in the Hamptons for a certain price.
Today, we’re going to take a look at the woodsy northwest neighborhood of Hampton Bays that hugs the bay: Red Creek.
19 Tanglewood Trail: $1,799,000
Sited on two acres of land, this 5,600-square-foot home has five bedrooms and five bathrooms. Four of the bedrooms are ensuite, and all of the bathrooms have been updated. Inside, there’s a double front entrance door, high ceilings, an open floor plan, and a finished walk-out lower level.
Outside, there’s a renovated pool and spa, and a deck.
49 Red Creek Road: $1,600,000
This post modern home with over 3,500 square feet has five bedrooms and four bathrooms on over three acres of land. A long driveway and fountain welcome homeowners, while inside one will find a chef’s kitchen with a breakfast area, a second-level master suite, and room for a gym or apartment in the lower level.
Outdoors, there’s a covered deck, bluestone patios, an outdoor kitchen with a pizza oven, and a pool. The property last sold in 2003 for $460,000 and has been available to rent in the past.
6 Squires Pond Road: $2,200,000
With 300 feet of frontage on Squires Pond, this 1.74-acre waterfront property with views of Peconic Bay has two legal dwellings on the property with special pre-exiting zoning rights. There’s a main house, guest cottage, and a detached two-car garage with a heated upper loft. The main house and guest cottage both have hardwood floors and vaulted ceilings, and have been recently updated.
Which Red Creek property would you want for around $2M?
This poll is closed
19 Tanglewood Trail: $1.799M
49 Red Creek Road: $1.6M
6 Squires Pond Road: $2.2M