Bayview cottage with potential in Shinnecock Hills wants $1.9M

The interiors of this waterview cottage at 13 Aqua Drive in Shinnecock Hills look like they’re in great shape—and we think that the 1,655-square-foot home could make a great fixer-upper.

Listed with Douglas Elliman agent Finley Behringer, the house is asking $1.9 million.

Sited on 0.4 acres of land overlooking Shinnecock Bay, the 1950 house includes three bedrooms, two full bathrooms, stainless steel appliances in the updated kitchen, hardwood floors, and a large bayview living room. There’s also a one-car garage in the basement.

If under 2,000 square feet is just too small, the listing claims that zoning would allow for a second story to be added to the existing house. There’s also room on the property to add a pool.

We want to hear from our readers: What do you think of the price? The Zillow price history states that it was listed for a lower $1,749,000 back in 2017, and estimates that it’s currently valued at around $915,000—but Zillow’s price estimates aren’t always accurate. Directly next door, the slightly larger house at 17 Aqua Drive—which has a pool and looks to have been updated a bit more recently—sold for $2.4 million in 2011.

Tell us your thoughts of the price in the comments.

For tips and corrections, please email hamptons@curbed.com

• 13 Aqua Drive [Douglas Elliman]