clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

How much for a shingled ‘cottage’ in north-of-the-highway Amagansett?

Try and guess this week’s PriceSpotter

Photos courtesy of Compass

Welcome to PriceSpotter, Curbed’s guessing game. Try to guess how much this place is asking—and remember, no cheating! Take our poll to tell us what you think the asking price is and we’ll reveal the listing on Thursday.


What do you think this shingled "cottage" in Amagansett is listed for?

This poll is closed

  • 28%
    Between $2.8M and $3.5M
    (16 votes)
  • 33%
    Between $3.5M and $4M
    (19 votes)
  • 24%
    Between $4M and $4.5M
    (14 votes)
  • 14%
    Over $4.5M
    (8 votes)
57 votes total Vote Now

What/Where: A shingled “cottage” in northern Amagansett
Size: 6,100 square feet, 2 acres

For this week’s PriceSpotter, Curbed is having readers try to guess the asking price of a handsome shingled cottage-style house spanning 6,100 square feet over nearly 2 acres of land in north-of-the-highway Amagansett.

Inside the estate, there are five bedrooms and five bathrooms, a two-story foyer, an open floorplan, and a chef’s kitchen. A fireplace and French doors leading outside are situated in the living room, while a two-bedroom guest suite provides guests with plenty of privacy. On the second level, the master suite includes a fireplace, private library, a private balcony, and an ensuite bathroom.

Outside, the property hosts a heated pool and a veranda.

We won’t reveal an address quite yet, but we will tell readers that the house is about 1 mile north of the Amagansett train station and about 2 miles from the ocean at the end of Atlantic Avenue.

The house was built in 2013, so it’s still relatively new. In 2015, the property sold for $2.8 million, so we’re going to start the guessing at the most recent sales price.

For tips and corrections, please email