clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

How much for this 19th century whaling captain’s home in Sag Harbor village?

New, 5 comments

Can you guess the asking price?

Photos courtesy of Sotheby’s

Welcome to PriceSpotter, Curbed’s guessing game. Try to guess how much this place is asking—and remember, no cheating! Take our poll to tell us what you think the asking price is and we’ll reveal the listing on Thursday.


What do you think this Sag Harbor home is listed for?

This poll is closed

  • 35%
    Under $3M
    (14 votes)
  • 32%
    Between $3M and $4M
    (13 votes)
  • 22%
    Between $4M and $5M
    (9 votes)
  • 10%
    Over $5M
    (4 votes)
40 votes total Vote Now

What/Where: A whaling captain’s cottage from 1820 in Sag Harbor village
Size: 2,780 square feet, 0.45 acres

This week, we’re having Curbed readers guess the asking price of a Sag Harbor village whaling cottage, originally built in the 1820s. The home spans a comfortable 2,780 square feet in size across a half-acre of land, with five bedrooms, five full bathrooms, and one half-bathroom.

Interiors were totally gutted according to the listing, and it’s been renovated and rebuilt. New additions include a new foundation, a new fully finished basement with its own entrance, and high ceilings. But for those who love a bit of history, some period details have been maintained, including the original molding and gas fireplace.

Outside, there’s a heated gunite pool.

In 2013, the property sold for $1.75 million after being on the market for $1,799,000. Since it’s been totally rebuilt, we’re going to start the guessing at $3 million.

For tips and corrections, please email

Sag Harbor

, , NY 11963