Big Reveal: $5.3M for a renovated Sag Harbor village home from 1830

New, 1 comment

Most readers were correct!

By Grace Cassidy Jan 18, 2018, 7:30am EST

1 comment / new

Poll

What do you think this Sag Harbor village cottage is listed for?

This poll is closed

37%

Under $5M

(26 votes)
47%

Between $5M and $7M

(33 votes)
8%

Between $7M and $9M

(6 votes)
2%

Between $9M and $10M

(2 votes)
2%

Over $10M

(2 votes)

69 votes total Vote Now

Earlier this week, we had readers guess the asking price of the nearly 200-year-old home at 39 Suffolk Street in Sag Harbor village.

The renovated home spans 3,000 square feet in size with four bedrooms and four full bathrooms on a quarter-acre of land. Though it’s been restored, it maintains some of the period details from the original construction, including four fireplaces and wide-plank flooring. Newer interior features include a professional grade kitchen with a white marble center island.

French doors lead to the exterior, which is host to separate studio cottage with a full bathroom, a heated saltwater pool, a sunbed on the lounging area, and an outdoor shower.

The home last sold back in 2013 for $1.25 million. Nearly half of our readers guessed in the correct category, thinking that it was between $5 million and $7 million. Another large portion of people thought that it was under $5 million, while less than 10 percent of voters guessed in the higher categories.