Located just a quarter mile from the beach, the home at 1919 Montauk Highway just came on the market for $845,000. The location is a big ambiguous, as it’s a bit past Napeague but not quite Montauk yet—but it’s also adjacent to Napeague State Park but more south than Napeague typically extends, so the listing claims it’s in Amagansett.
Standing 1,194 square feet, the home has three bedrooms and two bathrooms on 0.37 acres of land. Having undergone recent renovations, the interiors include an updated kitchen and living room with fireplace.
Outside, there’s a large deck with both covered and uncovered spaces, good for entertaining or outdoor dining. There are also some outdoor speakers already in place on the deck and hardwood floors throughout the interior.
The true downside is that it’s on the highway. If a homeowner can look past that aspect, the location here actually isn’t all that bad considering the proximity to the beach, Amagansett Square, and Montauk. And for being a five-minute walk from the beach in Amagansett, we won’t complain when it’s under $1 million.
Built in 1996, the home last sold in 2002 for $375,000. There aren’t too many homes for sale along Montauk Highway in the immediate nearby area, though a bit more east, comparable homes hover between $1.5 million and $2.5 million.
The home at 10 Gilbert Path in Amagansett—which sits right off Montauk Highway—is 1,341 square feet with four bedrooms and two bathrooms on 0.59 acres of land, with an asking price of $2,595,000.
- 1919 Montauk Highway [Halstead Property]