Address: 209 Old Northwest Road, East Hampton
Winner! The number one answer this week was correct. Commenters seemed a bit skeptical: "I would have this place clear cut immediately. Too woodsy." "The trees definitely need some thinning but overall, this looks like a really nice property." "It’s simply not clear to me why anyone would spend $3.5mm, let alone higher, to be in the woods." "Probably because it is a really beautiful house with a ton of SF and a beautiful pool and pool house on a lot of land in a nice quiet area. I mean other than that, no reason."