The best part about living in Hither Hills is the private beach access available to the Montauk Beach Property Owners' Association, which this house is eligible for.
It's spacious but not huge at 2200 square feet, with five bedrooms and three baths. (The lower level could be finished for additional space.) The blue painted kitchen, what looks like knotty pine floors, and Montauk stone fireplace are all attractive and homey, and the bathrooms are reasonably well updated. There's plenty of outdoor spaces with a wraparound porch, deck, and private balcony off the master. The downside is that with 0.17 acre of land, which looks like it slopes, there probably isn't room for a pool, but not everyone wants one. Go to the beach instead!
- 29 Hayes Road [Saunders]