clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

What You Can Buy in the Hamptons for $2.5M

Checking out properties in East Hampton, Sag Harbor, Amagansett, and more

Welcome back to Curbed Comparisons, a column that explores what you can rent or buy for a set dollar amount in various Hamptons towns. Is one person's studio another person's palace? Let's find out! Today's price: $2.5M.

↑ This three-bedroom in Sag Harbor Village is probably a teardown, though it does offer some charm with spacious living areas and renovated bathrooms. The real star here is the 0.91 acre of land, which is very close to Havens Beach, and is within walking distance of village shops and restaurants.

↑ Some pretty gardens overlook Mill Pond in Water Mill. This three bedroom is suffering from a painful 80s hangover, but some renovation of the 2500 square foot house could make it appealing, if it's not torn down. There's half an acre of land with a private dock on the lake and a gunite pool.

↑ This 80s house on prestigious Bull Run in Northwest Woods has funky charm indoors, along with a gigantic fieldstone fireplace, but an odd facade. There's nearly two acres of land, five bedrooms, 5.5 baths, a finished lower level, and was renovated with a new roof and kitchen in 2015.

↑ A harborfront property also in Northwest Woods is right across from idyllic Sammys Beach. Kayak or SUP from your own yard or cross the street to the white sand beach. The 1500 square foot house offers three bedrooms and two baths (and requires the new owner to ditch the Southwestern decor) and is set on 1.1 acre.

↑ This diminutive (1300 square feet) cottage is oceanfront at Amagansett's Ocean Colony Resort. There are three bedrooms and three baths and plenty of mahogany decking. As part of the resort, you can enjoy chair and towel service on the private beach, tennis courts, pool, clubhouse, and maid service.