clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Charming Shelter Island farmhouse with guest cottage asks $875K

Sweet as pie

This 1920s farmhouse includes many charming, homey details, such as the 1950s kitchen (shut up, we love it), enclosed front porch, and roomy screened porch out back. The house is 2000 square feet with three bedrooms and two baths; yes, it could be updated but is basically fine as is. There’s also a garage with art studio and a separate guest cottage with living room, kitchen, bedroom and bath. This is on 0.71 of an acre, which should theoretically permit room for a pool, if desired. Plus the property is close to Congdons Creek and the marina. We say go for it.

20 Congdon Road, Shelter Island