Address: 104 Georgica Close, East Hampton
Winner! The correct answer was the most popular choice this week, but that was all commenters could agree on. Some wanted the place torn down pronto: "Platform rooms only ever work in Broadway plays, not in real life. This dump is coming down, but the price must come down first." "Mr. Reagan....tear this 'mutha down! I say 12mil., not a penny more." "This place is a mess. Horrible floorplan. Your days are numbered, overpriced placeholder house." Others disagreed: "So easy to say tear down when it's not your money. This house is totally salvageable and could be gorgeous if renovated properly, at a fraction of the cost to rebuild it. Even that platform floor can be removed, as it should be. It needs a lot of work but tear down? No." "I love it. Just the furniture is bad, and the kitchen tile, the house itself is great, and the pool is amazing."
· How Much for a Two-Acre Teardown on Georgica Pond? [CH]
· 104 Georgica Close [Elliman]