Address: 14 McKinley Road, Montauk
Winner! The most popular guess this week was the actual asking price. We too think it's fairly reasonable for what you get. Not too many comments this week—the first was "Make a nice share house wouldn't it?" Oh ho ho, NOT FUNNY. Another commenter wrote, "Cute in a way but can it accommodate two cars?" We plugged the address into Bing Maps (which provides the best bird's eye view) and it looks like the house had two cars parked in front, so yeah. We wouldn't be surprised if this place was snapped up quickly.