Address: 625 Butter Lane, Bridgehampton
The most popular guess this week was $17.9M, so…bargain? Everyone seems to love this place: gorgeous house, lots of land, your own tree farm! (we think—this seems to be popular lately in the Hamptons to lower property taxes), beautiful pool, sunken tennis, everything. Comments included, "Whoa..nice...and ~500K of tree inventory," "It's GORGEOUS....and heartbreaking," and "This is spectacular. I'd consider north of the highway for this one."