Address: 21 Settlement Court, East Hampton
Not even close. We were pretty surprised by the asking price too, which is why we chose it for this week's quiz. One commenter wrote, "I like it. I guess you can actually make a silk purse out of a sow's ear." Another was unconvinced: "From the outside I thought it was my gynecologist office." (We also think the outside needs some help.) Another wrote, "I tried to convince a friend to buy this place a few years back. Think it was this place..on the market for a mil give or take two fifty." Price has gone up since then!