Address: 187 Division Street, Sag Harbor
Close but no cigar—the number one choice this week was $1.55M. However, the listing has disappeared from the Saunders site and HREO in the past two days. Was it something we said? One commenter wrote, "Great house in a great location. I purchased it for $375,000 in 1995." Someone else posted an old link to the house furnished and decorated, last time it was for sale, and it looked gorgeous. We'll be interested to see what happens with this property.