Address: 69A Greenwich Street, Montauk
Almost. The most popular guess this week was $2,750,000. The only comment was "Needs more wood." Yeah—it's a bit woodsy for our tastes too, especially since it's in Montauk, not the Adirondacks, but there's a lid for every pot, as the saying goes. The price seems a bit high to us, considering that the house is dated and there's no pool; we assume pricechops are in this property's future.