Address: 22 Prospect Ave, Shelter Island Heights
Winner! We guess that means this is a reasonable ask. The property last sold for $2.9M back in 2007, but clearly a lot was spent on the restoration. Commenters were bullish on the place: "Love it - only negative looks like no backyard." Another countered, "A waterfront property that elevated is a huge plus. The last thing you want is a level flat plot of land here." "That's a pretty impressive restoration. Can't help noticing the strange placement of a sofa blocking the fireplace in the master bedroom. That should have been moved for the photo. Who doesn't love a fireplace in the master?" And "Nice. Figured the entire price range would be higher though I'm not super familiar with SI pricing. Not a fan of the weird double islands in the kitchen."