How Much for an 1883 Mansion in Shelter Island Heights?

PriceSpotter is Curbed's price guessing game. We provide some details and pictures from a local listing, and you take a crack at the price. Thursday, we reveal the answer. No cheating!

What/Where: 7 bedrooms, 8 baths /Shelter Island Heights
Square Feet: 7165sf
Acreage: 1.87 acres
The Skinny: This 1883 house offers beautiful views and your own sandy beach. It was renovated in 2010, including a new foundation and systems, while retaining the charming original features. There's a covered waterside porch, a 50' pool, and a cabana in the walkout basement.

So...how much do you think they're asking for it?
· PriceSpotter Archive [CH]