Address: 24 High Street, Sag Harbor
Too easy? The most popular guess was correct this week, although commenters had some fun with it. "Should be: $495k. Is: $17mm because Sag Harbor." And "It's worth $2.55M just for the floor boards." Others groused about the clutter, which struck us as sweet and homey, after all the sterile staged pictures we see. "The clutter is a minor irritant. With a pool in place and some decluttering, this could be a sweet house."