Address: 47G South Ferry Road, Shelter Island
Located next to the Mashomack Preserve on Coecles Harbor, the property here is obviously all about the land value. (Maybe the new owners can use the current cottage as a shed…) Still, we were surprised at the price, and so were you readers, as $1M was the most common answer.
· Water Front Beach Cottage [Corcoran]
· How Much for a Tiny Cottage on Shelter Island? [CH]