Address: 4585 Noyac Road, Sag Harbor
Close, but no cigar. The actual price was the second most popular guess these week. Reader opinions on this were mixed. daveH wrote, "OMG I LOVE this place. great area. a bit lake-locked if you want to go boating it'll take a while to get to open waters ...WISH I HAD THOSE WORRIES!!! ..but max respect to the designers I think its spectacular!" Another commented, "Calling lovers of mosquitos and flooding!"
· Charming Sag Harbor Waterfront [BHS]
· How Much for This Creekside Sag Harbor Cottage? [Curbed Hamptons]