This is a cute, cozy (1346sf) affordable old house on Shelter Island. Built in 1889, the place could use some interior updates, but nothing a few cans of paint won't solve. We're in favor of keeping the cute vintage kitchen but we'd paint the ceiling beams. There's a full bath off the kitchen (odd, but whatever) and another upstairs, along with three bedrooms and another room that could work well as a playroom. Outside, there's almost half an acre, so plenty of room for a pool. Price is a reasonable $575,000.
· Vintage 1800s Farmhouse Near Beach [Saunders]