Big Reveal: How Much for This Wainscott Four-Bedroom?

Address: 15 Wainscott Hollow Road, Wainscott
Asking Price: $5.25M
Foiled again this week! The most popular guess this time was $4.95M, which is 300K less than the asking price. The house is south of the highway and offers a good-sized property at 1.63 acres. One commenter said, "Very elegant and tasteful, until you get to the non sequitur of a kitchen. The dark shingles really elevate this place." We agree—it's a nice property. We'd redo the kitchen too.
• Wainscott South [Corcoran]
• How Much for This Wainscott Four-Bedroom? [Curbed Hamptons]