If you're not opposed to spending your summer in North Haven (and you really shouldn't be?it's lovely), consider this five-bedroom on Forest Road. Overlooking both Sag Harbor Bay and Northwest Harbor, the 4000 sq. ft. home offers three master suites, a chef's kitchen, a pair of sitting rooms and a deck that will allow you to soak in "the most beautiful sunrises on the East coast." The 1.7 acre property only adds to the place's appeal as it boasts a basketball court, a waterside pool, 220 ft. of water frontage and a 250 ft. deep water dock with its own boat house. It may not be south of the highway, but the views should quickly make that a non-issue.