Location: 960 Springs Fireplace Rd., East Hampton
Most reader guesses were dramatically lower than this waterfront home's ask of $2.5 million. One commenter went as low as "$899k in this environment," while another noted that it's,"probably a fortune for flood insurance." Only guest #7 was in the ballpark and even then his "upwards of 2 million" guess still fell short of the property's price tag. It looks like it'll take a reasonably-sized price chop for this house to change hands.