clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Zagat's 2011/2012 Guide to the Best Hamptons Restaurants Is Here

New, 2 comments

The latest Zagat survey of the best Hamptons Restaurants has just been released and there are many, many familiar names on the list.

Snagging the top spot again with a near-perfect food score of 29 is the North Fork Table in Southold. And the top actually-in-the-Hamptons restaurant is Dave's Grill in Montauk, which raked in 27 food points.

One shocker with this year's survey is that the amazing Vine Street on Shelter Island received just 25 points for their food (down from 27 last year). But if this means it'll now be easier to get a reservation there this summer, then we can make peace with this inexplicable rating.

Highest Rated Restaurants by Food Score, 2011-12 Zagat Hamptons Survey
· (29) North Fork Table (American) - Southold
· (27) La Plage (Eclectic) - Wading River
· (27) Dave's Grill (Continental/Seafood) - Montauk
· (26) Starr Boggs (American/Seafood) - Westhampton Beach
· (26) Mirko's (Eclectic) - Water Mill
· (26) Plaza Café (Seafood) - Southampton
· (26) Stone Creek (French/Mediterranean) - East Quogue
· (26) Noah's (American) - Greenport
· (26) Harvest on Fort Pond (Italian/Mediterranean) - Montauk
· (26) The Palm (Seafood) - East Hampton
· (25) The Living Room (American) - East Hampton
· (25) Frisky Oyster (Eclectic) - Greenport
· (25) Robert's (Italian) - Water Mill
· (25) Luce & Hawkins (American) - Jamesport
· (25) Vine Street (American) - Shelter Island
· (25) 1770 House (American) - East Hampton
· (25) American Hotel (American/French) - Sag Harbor
· (25) Tutto il Giorno (Italian) - Sag Harbor
· (25) Amarelle (American) - Wading River
· (24) Oasis Waterfront (American) - Sag Harbor
· (24) Sant Ambroeus (Italian) - Southampton
· (24) Della Femina (American) - East Hampton (This has closed.)
· (24) Nick & Toni's (Italian/Mediterranean) - East Hampton
· (24) Philippe East (Chinese) - East Hampton (This has closed.)
· (24) A Mano (Italian) - Mattituck
· (24) Suki Zuki (Japanese) - Water Mill
· (24) Michael Anthony's (Eclectic) - Wading River

· Zagat - Long Island Restaurants [Official Site]
· All Previous Zagat Coverage [Curbed Hamptons]

Dave's Grill

468 West Lake Drive, Montauk, NY 11954 Visit Website