Southampton's own Tate's Bake Shop can now say that their cookie is #1, at least according to a Consumer Reports taste test. Tasters rated its "big butter and chocolate flavors and smooth chocolate chips" as excellent. But, like most things found in the Hamptons, the baked goods don't come cheap?
3 9 oz. of the recently copied cookie will set you back $18 (plus shipping!) on their website. [Previously, Consumer Reports]