Location: Toylsome Lane, Southampton (South of the Highway)
Curbed readers were all over the map on this one. Guesses ranged from $3M all the way up to "something exorbitant like $5.95mm". Only one commenter was dead on with a guess of $4.5M, noting that even with the home's desirable Tolysome Lane location, "it probably will sit for a while," unless there's "a 3 in front".
· Listing: Unmatched Value Off Little Plains Road [Sotheby's]
· Pricespotter: How Much For This Renovated Southampton Colonial? [Curbed Hamptons]