clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Top 10 Most Expensive Sag Harbor Waterfront Summer Rentals

Blizzard got you bummed out? Catch a glimpse of summer sun with our latest batch of Rental Specials. Today, we're on the lookout for Sag Harbor houses on the water. And since this is the East End's former whaling capital, we're only hunting for the big fish. Call us insatiable.
We've hooked the Most Expensive Summer Rentals On The Sag Harbor Waterfront:

10. The Rental: Modern Privacy
MD-LD: $130,000
The Skinny: Not a neighbor in sight with this secluded modern house situated on a bluff overlooking the bay. Private staircase takes you down to the water's edge.
Listing: Waterfront Seclusion [Elliman]

9. The Rental: Sweet Sunsets
MD-LD: $150,000
The Skinny: Privacy, sunsets and a bayside heated gunite pool included with this 6 bedroom traditional.
Listing: Sunset Traditional [Elliman]

8. The Rental: Commute By Boat
MD-LD: $180,000
The Skinny: Sail right up to your property with this 4 bedroom, 3 bath house on the bay that includes satellite TV and an indoor/outdoor surround sound system.
Listing: Waterfront Holiday [Corcoran]

7. The Rental: Bayfront Beauty
MD-LD: $195,000
The Skinny: A gorgeous village house with a heated pool on the water. Killer sunsets included.
Listing: Bayfront Village Gem [Saunders]

6. The Rental: Modern Waterfront
MD-LD: $210,000
The Skinny: A new modern home with a deep water dock on Sag Harbor Cove and over 125' of open waterfront.
Listing: Modernist Sag Harbor Waterfront [Corcoran]

5. The Rental: Bayfront Acreage
MD-LD: $225,000
The Skinny: Stunning mansion features 6,000 square feet with 5 bedrooms, 5 1/2 baths, and a heated pool on close to 2 acres of bayfront bliss.
Listing: Breathtaking Mansion [Main Street]

4. The Rental: Private Beach
MD-LD: $225,000
The Skinny: This 5 bedroom house includes a waterfront pool, dock and basketball court on a private beach.
Listing: Waterfront Compound [T&C]

3. The Rental: Tower Power
MD-LD: 225,000
The Skinny: Enjoy the view of Shelter Island from the limestone tower on this property that has 450' of waterfrontage.
Listing: C'est Oui [Simon Harrison]

2. The Rental: Peconic Bay Views
MD-LD: $350,000
The Skinny: The picture says it all. Infinity edge pool blends into the incredible views of Peconic Bay from this 7 bedroom house.
Listing: Waterfront Paradise [Sotheby's]


1. The Rental: The Big Whale
MD-LD: $395,000
The Skinny: Tops our list with 8,000 square feet set on 2 acres of prime village waterfront. Amenities include a wine tasting room, movie theater, billiards room, sauna, steam room and gym.
Listing: American Idyll [Saunders]